MCA vs. Term Loan: Understanding the True Cost Difference

Merchant cash advances (MCAs) are one of the most expensive forms of business financing. They also fund faster and approve borrowers others would decline. Understanding when MCAs make sense — and when they create debt traps — can save your business.

Here is an honest comparison with term loans.

Structural Differences

MCAs and term loans work completely differently:

Feature	Merchant Cash Advance	Term Loan
Legal Structure	Purchase of future receivables	Loan with defined terms
Cost Expression	Factor rate (1.1-1.5)	Interest rate (APR)
Repayment Method	Daily % of sales or fixed ACH	Fixed monthly payments
Repayment Amount	Fixed total regardless of time	Interest on declining balance
Prepayment Benefit	Usually none	Reduces total interest
Typical Term	3-18 months	1-25 years
Regulation	Less regulated	More regulated (Truth in Lending)

Cost Comparison

This is where the rubber meets the road:

Metric	MCA (1.35 factor)	Term Loan (18% APR)
Amount Received	$100,000	$100,000
Expected Term	12 months	36 months
Total Repayment	$135,000	$130,000
Cost	$35,000	$30,000
Effective APR	60-70%	18%
Daily Payment	~$520 (varies)	N/A
Monthly Payment	N/A	~$3,615

The Prepayment Trap

If you repay that MCA in 8 months instead of 12, your effective APR rises to 80-90%. With a term loan, early repayment saves money. With an MCA, you pay the same $135,000 whether it takes 6 months or 12.

Why MCAs Exist

Given the cost, why would anyone choose an MCA? Several reasons:

Speed — MCAs can fund in 24-48 hours versus weeks for term loans
Accessibility — MCAs approve borrowers with 500+ credit scores, limited history
No collateral — Based on sales history, not assets
Flexible qualification — Revenue matters more than credit
Simple process — Often just bank statements and a short application

The Access Trade-Off

MCAs serve businesses that cannot access other financing. If you have good credit and time, term loans cost less. If you have poor credit and need money tomorrow, MCAs may be your only option.

When an MCA Might Make Sense

Despite the cost, MCAs can be appropriate in specific situations:

True emergency — You will lose more money without capital than the MCA costs
Time-sensitive opportunity — A deal that expires before term loans would fund
No other options — Banks and online lenders have declined you
Very short-term need — You need $20,000 for 30 days and will absolutely repay
High-margin business — Your margins can absorb the cost (dangerous assumption)

Danger Signs

If you are taking an MCA because you cannot make payroll, or to pay off another MCA, stop. This is how debt spirals start. Seek credit counseling or restructuring advice instead.

When to Avoid MCAs

MCAs are usually wrong when:

You could qualify for other financing — Even 25% APR term loans cost less
The need is not urgent — If you can wait weeks, wait for cheaper money
You are already carrying MCA debt — Stacking MCAs is extremely dangerous
The cost will hurt margins — If 30-60% financing cost makes you unprofitable
You do not have a clear repayment path — How exactly will you repay?
You are using it for working capital — Ongoing needs should not be funded by 60% APR debt

The Stacking Problem

MCA "stacking" is when businesses take multiple advances. This is extremely dangerous:

MCA 1: $50,000 at 1.3 factor = $65,000 repayment ($500/day)
Business struggles: Take MCA 2 to cover costs
MCA 2: $40,000 at 1.35 factor = $54,000 repayment ($450/day)
Combined daily payment: $950/day = $285,000+ annually
Result: Business cannot sustain $285,000/year in debt service

The Spiral

Once you are in MCA stacking, escape is difficult. You are paying $1,000+/day to debt while trying to run a business. Many businesses in this situation need to consider restructuring, negotiation, or bankruptcy.

Qualification Comparison

Requirement	MCA	Term Loan
Credit Score	500+ often OK	620-680+ typically
Time in Business	3-6 months	1-2 years
Annual Revenue	$100,000+	$100,000-$250,000+
Bank Statements	3-4 months	6-12 months
Tax Returns	Usually not required	Usually required
Collateral	None (sales-based)	Often required
Approval Time	Hours	Days to weeks

Alternatives to Consider

Before taking an MCA, explore these options:

Invoice factoring — Advance on specific invoices, often cheaper than MCAs
Business line of credit — Flexible access without factor rates
SBA Microloan — For smaller amounts ($50K or less) with better terms
Equipment financing — If you need equipment, it can be collateral
Revenue-based financing — Similar structure, sometimes better terms
Credit cards — For very small, short-term needs (yes, really)

Comparison Shopping

If you are considering an MCA, spend 48 hours checking alternatives first. Apply to 3-4 lenders. You might qualify for something better than you expect.

Questions to Ask MCA Providers

If you decide to pursue an MCA, get clear answers:

What is the factor rate? — Get the exact number
What is the total repayment amount? — The clearest cost measure
What is the estimated APR? — Reputable providers will tell you
What are the daily/weekly payments? — Know exactly what leaves your account
What happens if sales drop? — Some adjust; others do not
Are there prepayment benefits? — Most MCAs say no, but ask
Are there origination or closing fees? — Get all costs upfront

The Bottom Line

MCAs are expensive because they take risk that other lenders will not. For businesses with no other options and a genuine short-term need, they provide access that did not exist 20 years ago.

But for most businesses, MCAs should be a last resort. The cost is 3-5x higher than term loans. If you can possibly qualify for other financing, pursue it first.

And if you are already in MCA debt and considering another advance, stop and get advice. Stacking rarely ends well.

MCA vs. Term Loan: Understanding the True Cost Difference

Try Our Free Calculator